Setting the Stage: A Glimpse into our Ford vs. Buick Face-off
Welcome to our in-depth review, where we compare the 2023 Ford Explorer and the 2023 Buick Enclave, two formidable contenders in the mid-size SUV market. Crafted by the seasoned auto experts at Dorian Ford in Clinton Township, MI, this face-off offers a unique blend of user-centric perspectives, rigorous evaluations, and comprehensive comparisons.
In one corner, we have the 2023 Ford Explorer, a nameplate that has established itself as a household staple since its advent in 1991. The current model marks its fourth year, standing tall with a spacious interior that includes a third row, striking exterior aesthetics, and a diverse range of powertrain options. Ford's Explorer is not just a vehicle, but a reliable companion that goes beyond the call of duty. Whether it's accommodating a large family, stowing away vacation luggage, or even showcasing agility with its high-performance variant, the Explorer is a force to be reckoned with. The addition of the off-road-oriented Explorer Timberline variant further solidifies its dominance in the SUV arena.
In the opposing corner stands the 2023 Buick Enclave, Buick's response to the intensifying competition in the mid-size luxury SUV segment. Under the hood lies a smooth 3.6-liter V-6 engine, and within its confines, you'll find a tranquil cabin designed for relaxing journeys. While it does offer a nice roster of standard features, some might argue that the Enclave lacks the refined aura found in its European counterparts.
As we proceed, we'll unravel the unique traits of each model and highlight their advantages and drawbacks. Our goal is to help you understand the nuances that distinguish these vehicles and guide you towards a decision that aligns with your lifestyle, whether you're seeking family-centric utility, outdoor adventure-readiness, or a balance of comfort and functionality. So, buckle up and join us as we delve into this engaging Ford vs. Buick face-off!
Visual Majesty: Comparing the Stately Exteriors of Explorer and Enclave
The exterior of a vehicle often acts as a window into its soul, revealing much about its character and capabilities. In our comparison today, the 2023 Ford Explorer and the Buick Enclave display unique design languages, each appealing to a distinct set of buyers. Yet, as we delve deeper, the Explorer's exterior outshines its competitor in several compelling ways.
Embodying a blend of robustness and elegance, the 2023 Ford Explorer offers a visual feast with its eight trim levels - Base, XLT, ST-Line, Timberline, Limited, ST, Platinum, and King Ranch. Each trim carries its distinctive style, reflecting the versatile capabilities of the Explorer. The ST-Line and ST trims, for instance, exude an aggressive aura, highlighting their track-bred performance. The Timberline is geared for adventures with skid plates, a cargo carrier, an off-road light kit, and overmolded fenders, ideal for those outdoor enthusiasts seeking an SUV that mirrors their adventurous spirit. For those leaning towards luxury, the Limited and Platinum models don chrome and aluminum accents, delivering a premium ambiance.
The color options for the Explorer are expansive, ranging from the sophisticated Agate Black Metallic, through the serene Stone Blue Metallic and Carbonized Gray Metallic, to the vibrant Rapid Red Metallic. With such a spectrum of choices, families can select a color that resonates with their personality and lifestyle.
In contrast, the Buick Enclave showcases an aesthetic that leans towards elegance and uniformity. Its sleek design, complemented by flowing body lines and a signature light design, was refreshed in 2022. The Enclave does offer some visual variety with the sportier look of the Sport Touring Edition and the more premium feel of the Avenir trim. However, it is the Explorer's range of trims and the unique character each brings that truly stands out in this comparison.
The Enclave is on the larger side of midsize SUVs, similar in size to the Chevrolet Traverse and Volkswagen Atlas. Its multi-spoke aluminum wheels, LED daytime running lights, and hands-free power liftgate do add to its appeal. The available color options, including Sage Metallic and Emperor Blue Metallic, offer a sense of luxury and sophistication.
Yet, it is the Ford Explorer that takes the lead in this exterior comparison, offering a superior blend of style, versatility, and personalization. Whether you prioritize family-oriented design, outdoor readiness, or a blend of comfort and utility, the Explorer's exterior design strikes a harmonious balance between all these elements, making it a compelling choice in the midsize SUV segment.
Indulgence Inside: A Peek into the Comfort and Elegance of Explorer and Enclave Interiors
Choosing the perfect vehicle often boils down to the experience inside the cabin. As such, the interiors of the 2023 Ford Explorer and the Buick Enclave invite scrutiny, offering unique settings that cater to the needs of families, outdoor enthusiasts, and those who prioritize comfort and utility. Yet, in this comparison, the Explorer's interior offers a more balanced and user-friendly environment.
The Ford Explorer's cabin, focusing on functionality and comfort, provides a pleasant setting for journeying through life's adventures. The design might seem restrained, but it serves a purpose, ensuring every element is within easy reach and use. The first two rows offer a cozy seating experience, facilitating long, enjoyable trips on the road. A convenient mechanism provides easy access to the standard third row, making it a breeze for children to move in and out of the seats during those family outings.
When it comes to cargo space, the Explorer does not disappoint. The spacious interior accommodates four carry-on suitcases behind the third row, catering to the needs of families planning a weekend getaway or outdoor enthusiasts gearing up for their next adventure. Furthermore, with both back rows folded flat, the Explorer opens up a generous space that can hold up to 31 bags, according to Car & Driver, an attribute that those who prioritize utility will certainly appreciate.
On the other hand, the Buick Enclave does bring a roomy interior to the table, equipped with several comfort and convenience features. The design is aesthetically pleasing and practical, though some might find the material quality and attention to detail lacking, especially when compared to luxury-branded rivals. The presence of low-grade wood trim and manual sunshades for the optional panoramic roof might detract from the premium feel. Furthermore, only the passenger-side second-row seat slides forward for third-row access, which, although a cost-saving measure, could compromise convenience.
Where the Enclave does excel is in the sheer volume of cargo space. It offers the most cubic feet of storage space in its class, accommodating an impressive 38 carry-on boxes with all seats down and space for five carry-ons behind the third row. However, it's important to note that while quantity is certainly an advantage, the overall utility and comfort, as well as the user-friendliness of the interior layout, are equally crucial.
In the comparison of these SUV interiors, the 2023 Ford Explorer takes the lead with its balanced approach towards comfort, user-friendliness, and utility. Whether you're a family planning a road trip, an outdoor enthusiast setting out on an off-road escapade, or someone who values a comfortable, user-friendly cabin, the Explorer offers an interior setting that caters to all these needs.
Heart of the Beast: Delving into Engine, Transmission, and Performance Dynamics
Choosing between the 2023 Ford Explorer and the Buick Enclave might require a closer look at the heart of these beasts - their engines, transmissions, and overall performance. In this respect, the Explorer offers a more versatile and impressive range of powertrain options.
The Explorer offers a choice of engines to suit different preferences. Base, XLT, and Limited trims come with a 300-hp turbocharged 2.3-liter four-cylinder engine that provides an ample amount of power, as evidenced by a quick 0 to 60 mph sprint in just 6.0 seconds in Car & Driver's tests. For those craving more power, the King Ranch, Platinum, or ST models deliver with a robust 400-hp twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter V-6 engine.
For those leaning towards a greener alternative, the Explorer presents a hybrid option that debuted in 2020. It combines a 3.3-liter V-6 engine with an electric motor, providing a combined output of 318 horsepower. This hybrid configuration, available for Limited and Platinum models, appeals to those seeking improved city fuel efficiency. But if highway efficiency is a priority, the standard turbocharged four-cylinder engine proves to be a compelling choice.
Regardless of the engine choice, the Explorer offers a 10-speed automatic transmission as standard. The ride and handling are comfortable and composed, although those seeking a more engaging drive will appreciate the athletic prowess of the Explorer ST. With its extra power, stiffer suspension, and optional all-wheel drive, it truly elevates the Explorer into the realm of performance SUVs. And for the outdoor enthusiasts planning to tow their recreational gear or families thinking about a trailer for their road trips, the Explorer boasts an impressive towing capacity of up to 5600 pounds when properly equipped.
The Enclave, in contrast, offers a one-size-fits-all approach with a single engine option - a 3.6-liter V-6 engine generating 310 horsepower. This engine, paired with a nine-speed automatic transmission, allows the Enclave to reach 60 mph in 6.5 seconds. The performance is adequate for most driving situations, and the engine maintains a quiet demeanor, ensuring a peaceful cabin environment. While it does not offer the sporty handling of some competitors, the Enclave focuses on comfort, offering a nice ride that smoothly absorbs road imperfections. As for towing, the Enclave is capable, but with a maximum capacity of 5000 pounds, it trails the Explorer.
In this heart-to-heart comparison, the 2023 Ford Explorer clearly outshines its competitor. With a wider range of powertrain options, superior towing capacity, and an athletic performance variant in the form of the Explorer ST, it offers a more comprehensive package that appeals to a broader spectrum of drivers, from families to outdoor enthusiasts and those prioritizing comfort and utility.
Fuel-Savvy Cruisers: Weighing the Fuel Efficiency of Explorer and Enclave
In today's world, fuel efficiency is a pivotal factor that goes hand in hand with performance when choosing an SUV. In this section, we'll be comparing the fuel efficiency of the 2023 Ford Explorer and the 2023 Buick Enclave, shedding light on the importance of economical cruising without compromising on the driving experience.
The 2023 Ford Explorer showcases versatility, not only in its performance and style but also in its fuel efficiency. With multiple powertrain and drivetrain combinations, the Explorer offers a variety of EPA fuel-economy ratings. Leading the pack in frugality is the rear-drive hybrid model, boasting impressive EPA estimates of up to 27 mpg in the city and 28 mpg on the highway. Even the more luxurious Platinum hybrid models offer admirable fuel efficiency with ratings of 25 mpg city and 26 mpg highway. If you opt for the added confidence of all-wheel drive, the hybrid's city rating is still a respectable 23 mpg. These figures demonstrate the Explorer's commitment to providing an economical drive, no matter your choice of model or powertrain.
Moving to the 2023 Buick Enclave, the story is slightly different. While no one expects compact-car-like fuel efficiency from a sizable three-row SUV like the Enclave, fuel economy is still a crucial consideration. The front-wheel-drive version of the Enclave comes with a combined EPA rating of 21 mpg, broken down into 18 mpg in the city and 26 mpg on the highway. Opting for the all-wheel-drive variant drops the combined mpg to 20, with city and highway ratings of 17 and 25 mpg, respectively. In real-world testing, the all-wheel-drive Enclave Avenir achieved its promised 25 mpg on the highway. These figures are decent for a vehicle of its size but fall slightly short when compared to the Explorer's hybrid offerings.
Both the Explorer and Enclave offer respectable fuel efficiency for their class, each with its unique set of strengths. The Ford Explorer, with its hybrid options, presents a more fuel-efficient choice, particularly for city drivers and those with a focus on sustainability. The Buick Enclave, on the other hand, delivers decent fuel economy for its size, making it a suitable choice for those who prioritize spaciousness and comfort. As always, the final decision rests on aligning your personal preferences and driving habits with what each model has to offer.
Pulling Power: Towing Capacity - Explorer vs. Enclave
For outdoor enthusiasts, families planning a vacation, or anyone requiring extra hauling capability, towing capacity is a crucial factor when choosing an SUV. Today, we're comparing the towing capabilities of the 2023 Ford Explorer and the 2023 Buick Enclave. Let's dive in to see how these two titans stack up.
The 2023 Ford Explorer, with its robust architecture and strong powertrain options, boasts impressive towing abilities. The Class IV Trailer Tow Package equips the Explorer with a maximum tow rating of up to 5,600 lbs when paired with the available 3.0L EcoBoost V6 engine. That's more than enough capacity for hauling a sizeable camper or a boat for a weekend getaway. Even with the standard turbo 2.3L EcoBoost I-4 engine, the Explorer doesn't disappoint, delivering a substantial towing capacity of up to 5,300 lbs. Opting for the environmentally friendly Hybrid powertrain still gets you a respectable 5,000 lbs of towing prowess. With such numbers, the Explorer confidently stands tall, ready for your adventurous lifestyle.
Now, let's shift our focus to the 2023 Buick Enclave. This contender offers consistent towing capacities across its different configurations. Without the V92 Trailering Package, the 2023 Buick Enclave has a maximum trailer weight rating of 1,500 lbs. It's a fair start but certainly feels a bit limiting for those who need to tow larger loads. However, with the addition of the V92 Trailering Package, the Enclave's towing capacity jumps to a more substantial 5,000 lbs, matching the base Explorer. This rating is consistent across all trim levels and drivetrains.
Summing it up, both the Explorer and Enclave have commendable towing capabilities, each catering to different needs. The Ford Explorer, with its superior towing capacity across all models, provides a clear advantage for those who require robust hauling power, whether for work or leisure. The Buick Enclave, on the other hand, offers consistent towing capacity, but it requires an additional package to match the Explorer's base model. The choice, as always, depends on your individual requirements and how each vehicle aligns with your lifestyle.
Guardian Angels: Safety Features and Peace of Mind in Explorer and Enclave
When it comes to choosing a vehicle, safety is paramount, especially for families and those frequently embarking on long trips. With that in mind, we'll compare the safety and driver-assistance features of the 2023 Ford Explorer and the 2023 Buick Enclave.
The Ford Explorer goes above and beyond when it comes to safety. Ford equips every Explorer with a comprehensive suite of standard driver-assistance technologies, ensuring peace of mind on every journey. This includes standard forward-collision warning and automated emergency braking, which can help prevent accidents before they happen. The Explorer also provides standard blind-spot monitoring and rear-cross-traffic alert, enhancing your awareness of your surroundings and adding an extra layer of safety. The standard lane-departure warning and lane-keeping assist can gently guide the vehicle back to its lane if any unintentional drifting is detected. Even in challenging driving conditions, the Explorer works tirelessly to keep you and your loved ones safe and secure.
Now, turning to the Buick Enclave, it comes with its own set of standard driver-assistance technologies, even on the base Preferred model. These include standard automated emergency braking with pedestrian detection and standard lane-keeping assist with lane-departure warning. Both of these features help protect not only the vehicle occupants but also those around the vehicle. For those seeking additional safety features like adaptive cruise control, you would need to consider a higher trim or purchase an optional package.
Both the Explorer and Enclave make safety a priority, coming equipped with a solid range of standard safety and driver-assistance features. However, the Ford Explorer offers a more comprehensive suite as standard across all trims, ensuring high safety levels no matter which version you opt for. The Buick Enclave, while providing a decent safety package, requires an upgrade or additional package for certain features. When it comes to safety, the Explorer's generosity with standard features could tip the scales for many drivers.
Tech-Savvy Travel: Innovative Technology and Connectivity Features Face-off
As modern-day vehicles become increasingly integrated with technology, it's more important than ever to consider the connectivity and infotainment options when choosing a vehicle. In this section, we'll compare the tech features of the 2023 Ford Explorer and the 2023 Buick Enclave.
The Ford Explorer embraces modern technology with a host of connectivity and infotainment options. The standard 8.0-inch touchscreen infotainment system offers both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto capability, allowing seamless smartphone integration for easy access to music, navigation, and apps on the go. The system is visually appealing and responsive, allowing for smooth operation. A Wi-Fi hotspot is also standard, providing internet access even when you're on the road, a boon for keeping passengers entertained during long trips. For those seeking an even larger display, an optional 10.1-inch vertically oriented screen is available on the higher trims. Voice-activated navigation and a rear-seat entertainment system are available options across all models, increasing the versatility of your driving experience. Apart from the base Explorer, a 12-speaker B&O stereo system comes standard, providing excellent audio quality for all your music and media needs.
The Buick Enclave also offers a solid range of tech features. The standard 8.0-inch IntelliLink touchscreen infotainment system is nestled into the dash, featuring a user-friendly interface and crisp graphics. Like the Explorer, the Enclave also provides standard wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto for convenient smartphone integration. The onboard Wi-Fi hotspot allows for internet connectivity on the move, and optional navigation provides real-time traffic and weather updates. A wireless charging pad for smartphones is an available option, and every row of seating comes equipped with two USB ports for device charging.
The Explorer and the Enclave both offer comprehensive and robust infotainment and connectivity features. The Ford Explorer, however, goes the extra mile by offering a larger optional display and a superior standard sound system on most trims. The Explorer also allows for voice-activated navigation and a rear-seat entertainment system across all models, further enhancing its appeal. While the Buick Enclave offers a solid tech package, certain features like the wireless charging pad and real-time navigation updates come at an extra cost.
The Final Verdict: Unraveling the Winning SUV
After an in-depth comparison, it becomes clear that the 2023 Ford Explorer edges out the Buick Enclave in many areas, making it the more balanced choice for families, outdoor enthusiasts, and comfort seekers.
With its robust selection of engines, the Explorer offers a versatile driving experience that ranges from eco-friendly to performance-focused. Its towing capacity outshines the Enclave, catering well to those who love outdoor adventures or have heavy-duty requirements.
The Explorer's interior strikes an excellent balance between comfort, practicality, and user-friendliness. Even though the Enclave offers a larger cargo space, the Explorer's thoughtful layout and high-quality materials make it a more appealing choice for those seeking a premium feel.
In terms of fuel efficiency, the Explorer shines, especially with its hybrid variant, offering a more economical drive than the Enclave. The Explorer's infotainment system, coupled with its standard 12-speaker B&O stereo system (in all but the base model), gives it a slight edge over the Enclave in terms of connectivity and entertainment options.
While the Enclave has its strengths, such as a quiet cabin and a slightly easier-to-use infotainment system, the Explorer's overall package is more appealing for a wider range of drivers.
Feel the Thrill: Join Us at Dorian Ford for a Test Drive
Reading about the 2023 Ford Explorer's superiority is one thing, experiencing it firsthand is another. We encourage you to visit us at Dorian Ford in Clinton Township, MI to test drive the Explorer. Our auto experts are ready to walk you through its features and answer any questions you may have.
Whether you are planning a family road trip, seeking your next adventure, or just need a reliable SUV for your daily commute, the Explorer is ready to exceed your expectations. Come feel the thrill and experience the superiority of the 2023 Ford Explorer today at Dorian Ford. We look forward to serving you.
